Magazines and Motorized Personal Transport

Penrhyn Stanlaws, Metropolitan, January 1916

Figure 1

Magazine Cover Images of Motorized Personal Transportation in the 1910s

Reflecting and Effecting Changing Times

By June S. Knopf

Note to Readers: Layout of this piece is being updated. Most of the figures remain to be uploaded. Click for the full collection of images in slightly different order. — March 2016.


The automobile was invented by the late 1800s, but it was not until 1908 that Henry Ford produced his Model T cars using assembly line manufacturing, thus drastically reducing the cost of car ownership.[1] Andrew Strieber acknowledged the significance of this milestone on its centennial in a July 2008 Motor Trend article: “Henry Ford’s creation was the first car specifically designed for the average consumer and helped create the era of personal transportation we know today.”[2] The “era of personal transportation” that Strieber references affected much more than commuting. The affordability and speed of personal transportation—including automobiles, motorcycles, and racecars—also expanded recreation and travel pursuits. Additionally, these vehicles altered familial relationships and relationships between men and women.

The dramatic shift in transportation and its effect on American life was often pictured on magazine cover illustrations that were distributed nationwide during the 1910s. This evolved as a result of the explosive growth of magazine publishing and illustration “in the last decades of the nineteenth century” that was termed “the birth of the modern national magazine” by Theodore Peterson, author of Magazines in the Twentieth Century, and which continued into the early twentieth century.[3] Magazines were no longer just for the elite. The combination of a well-educated pubic and technological advances including the rotary press and the halftone photographic color printing process, led to the nationwide distribution of all kinds of magazines that were increasingly well-illustrated.[4] Since, at the time, newspapers could only reach local audiences—and radio, television, and the internet had not yet been invented—magazines served as a major form of mass communication.

Nationally circulated, these highly appealing and colorful magazines helped unify the country. Their purpose was to enlighten and entertain. Magazines—through words and pictures—disseminated information about new nationally-distributed brands and products, innovations, styles, and ways of living. Heavily illustrated magazines promoted a popular visual culture that extended to all parts of the nation. They informed as well as influenced—economically, culturally, and politically. Likewise, through their visual impact, magazine cover illustrations enlightened and entertained just as the magazine as a whole. The visual impact of the magazine cover—part of what distinguished a magazine from a book or newspaper—had much to do with its periodic nature. Non-daily publishing allowed time for the creation of the covers’s alluring designs and illustration which served as advertisements, persuading the public to purchase the magazine either on the newsstand or by subscription.

"His First Tour, as It Seemed to Him," Life, January 6, 1910

Figure 2

The periodic nature of magazines also resulted in another role for magazine covers: the mass media conveyance of significant messages. Free of daily deadlines, magazine cover illustrators in the 1910s had time to ponder and aesthetically express their own pictorial view of current events and the exciting changes in society that were occurring during their lifetime. Judgments or persuasive messages contained in the cover illustration were those of the illustrator, albeit with the approval of art editors and magazine publishers. Illustrators often used humor or narrative story-telling techniques in combination with artistry, adding to entertainment value as well as persuasiveness. By representing the changes of the 1910s, cover illustrations reinforced and granted credence to historic events, easing their acceptance by magazine readers throughout the nation. In doing so, magazine cover illustrations not only reflected but also helped mold American history and culture.

In addition to boosting magazine sales and conveying persuasive messages (subtle or obvious), magazine cover illustrations had an important role in reinforcing art appreciation. Tebbel and Zuckerman, authors of The Magazine in America: 1741-1990, credit the Centennial Exposition of 1876 in Philadelphia for contributing to Americans’s new desire for art, noting that numerous visitors were exposed to art for the first time. Magazines, which contained art reproductions, furthered this interest.[5] The American Art Review, in an 1880 quote provided by Tebbel and Zuckerman, stated: “Within the last ten years, a great change has taken place in public sentiment. The arts are no longer regarded as comparatively unimportant to our national growth and dignity, and an ever increasing enthusiasm has replaced languid interest or indifference.”[6] It is fascinating to note that the latter article was published in 1880 the same time (“the last decades of the nineteenth century”) Peterson uses for the introduction of the modern national magazine.[7] By including art reproductions and illustrations in their pages and on their covers, nationally distributed magazines assisted in introducing Americans to the enjoyment of art on a wider scale. Art was no longer limited to the few who had access to museums and galleries.

The “Golden Age” of illustration coincided with the emergence of the modern magazine and Americans’s expanded interest in art. Walt Reed (illustrator, illustration gallery owner, author, and illustration expert) writes that the “Golden Age” began in the 1880s, and he elaborates on the excellent opportunities it provided for illustrators:

In short, the country was prosperous, circulation of the magazines was increasing from month to month with new publications emerging to compete with the older ones; prosperous magazines could afford the best talents and paid higher fees to the writers and artists who illustrated them. Artists responded with great enthusiasm to this national showcase for their pictures. The better illustrators had more work offered to them than they could handle, opening up opportunities for new talents. Full-color printing soon became possible. Through their appearances accompanying fiction within and covers on the outside, magazine illustrators became celebrities with coteries of fans and followers.[8]

In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the growing field of illustration offered impressive financial rewards for both men and women. The unnamed writer of “A Latter-Day Industry and its Rewards” (1910) portrays, perhaps longingly, the high life achieved by high earning illustrators of both sexes:

In this day and generation the chug-chug of a $15,000 motor car clipping its mile-a-minute rush toward a luxurious country home is best in keeping with the man or woman whose genius has concentrated upon a certain type, preferably a girl and emphasized in colors, to be spread country wide through the medium of the big magazines, calendars, gift books, and even postal cards![9]

The writer speaks of the “Commercialism with a capital C” which leads to high salaries, and includes a listing of top illustrators and their earnings. These earnings, the writer adds, “represent what might be termed the public earnings; many have private ones as well.”[10]

The reported earnings listed range from Harrison Fisher’s $75,000 to $7,500 earned by Hamilton King, John Cecil Clay, Walter Taylor, F.C. Yohn, and H.C. Raleigh. Even the lower earnings were ten times higher than the decade of 1910 to 1919’s average salary of $750.[11] Also, the 1910 earnings figures refer to that point in time; they do not reflect potentially higher earnings of illustrators whose achievements continued to escalate. For example, James Montgomery Flagg’s listed 1910 earnings of $15,000 likely increased dramatically after he became known for his famous image of Uncle Sam which first appeared on the cover of the July 6, 1916 Leslie’s magazine.[12] It was later used as a recruiting poster for both World War I and World War II, incorporating the words “I WANT YOU.”[13] Jessie Wilcox Smith probably earned more than $12,000 annually after she began creating her endearing Good Housekeeping cover images (often portraying children) which appeared each month from December 1917 through April 1933.[14]

The article ends with a statement about what the public was demanding of illustrations in 1910, and how meeting the demand created high illustrator remuneration:

No magazine editor will to-day venture a guess as to what the future will bring forth in still higher prices, but it is certain now that the illustrators have them on the run—for the simple reason that the public wants pretty girls and cute children or designs which artistically appeal—and color, color, color![15]

In other words, public demand for colorful illustrations—and increased sales of magazines that met that demand—justified the excellent compensation commanded by top illustrators. This symbiotic relationship between magazine publishing and illustration allowed for the blossoming of both industries. As the public bought more magazines because of their appealing cover and interior illustrations, increased magazine circulations allowed magazines to compensate illustrators well. This, in turn, sparked illustrators’s creativity.

Unsurprisingly, cover illustrators for major magazines were among the most capable and well-known artists of their time. While some illustrators preferred to be recognized primarily for their fine art and worked as illustrators to help pay bills (John Sloan comes to mind), others were proud of the status and compensation that came with being an illustrator. Patricia Frantz Kery, in Great Magazine Covers of the World, raises the often repeated question of the difference between fine art and illustrative art. Referring to her study of one hundred and fifty years of cover art from many countries, she states:

It can be seen clearly, for instance, from such an overview that before the mid-1920’s there was often little difference between fine and commercial art. Artists, especially around the turn of the century, saw art as art and did not see it as less grand just because it was reproduced for a magazine (as some would suppose today). Rather, cover work enhanced their reputations because more people became aware of their work.[16]

Viewing magazine cover illustrations from the 1910s leaves little question of their artistic impressiveness, whether one considers them art or illustration—or both.

In sum, magazine cover illustrations in the 1910s served three important roles. They boosted magazine sales, provided messages to help readers adapt to modern changes, and encouraged art appreciation. Their broad influence ranged from matters of great importance such as war and peace to matters of less significance such as women’s changing styles of dress. In-between are matters of considerable importance such as influencing technological developments and urbanization, new roles for women, and the creation of a consumer-based economy, which—as they pertain to the rapid shift to motorized personal transportation—form the focus of this article.


Magazine Cover Images of Automobiles, Racecars, and Motorcycles

Automobiles began appearing frequently on magazine covers almost immediately following the development of the Model T, both reflecting and stimulating interest in motoring. Car ownership expanded so rapidly that by 1915, according to 1001 Places to Sell Manuscripts, there were at least nineteen of these special interest magazines published in New York City including American Motorist, Automobile, Automobile Magazine, Automobile Topics, Horseless Age, Motor, Motor Life & Motor Print, and Motor World.[17] The large number of automobile interest magazines is evidence that automobiles were becoming a common part of the landscape. The frequent depiction of cars on the covers of general interest magazines as well as the proliferation of special interest magazines confirms that cars were indeed impacting the lives of people throughout America.

The rapid transition from horse-drawn carriages to motorized personal vehicles would have far reaching effects on all aspects of American society. Suburbs expanded, horse manure dwindled, and bicycle sales plummeted.[18] The economy boomed with the growth of burgeoning industries including the automobile and motorcycle industries, gas stations, repair shops, auto parts businesses, and road building. Seemingly unrelated businesses also expanded as a result of the changeover in transportation, which allowed the populace to venture further from their homes. These included motion pictures and movie theaters; camping, recreation and travel; magazine publishing which addressed all these new interests; and eventually shopping centers, malls, and fast food restaurants. Those who drove motorized vehicles—both men and women—gained a newfound independence from the ability to travel wherever and whenever they wanted. This affected relationships as well as lifestyles. Accordingly, emphasis was placed on the joyfulness and freedom of car ownership, with frequent images of families and romantic couples traveling together.

Americans were instantly drawn to the appeal of motorized vehicles notwithstanding some initial trepidation. Life, a refined humor magazine, addressed both the attraction of the automobile as well as the concerns surrounding it in its January 6, 1910 issue “Auto Number.” An amusing article, “The Lure of the Auto,” explains why “lots of people who lived simply and thriftily and seemed to be interested in saving money have suddenly let thrift go hang and blossomed out on the road in motor cars.” According to the unnamed writer, the answer is three-fold: First, the auto “does not eat. . . . Nobody has got to stay with it, nor bring it oats, water or hay, nor clean out its stall.” The second reason for the “comprehensiveness of its appeal” is that “everybody can enjoy it….Nobody is too young, too old, too big, too small, too ignorant or too wise to find a pleasure or a use in them.” The third reason is that autos “call for only one thing—time—a thing that everybody has got.” The article concludes that “it is lucky that autos are dear. If they were not, there would be so many of them that there would not be room on the earth for the folks to move about.”[19]

Life, January 6, 1910, "Here Endeth the First Lesson"

Figure 3

Cartoons contained in this special auto issue poke fun at the many new concerns of driving: learning how to drive and the potential for crashes (Figure 3), rolling off cliffs (Figure 2 and 4), and harming animals (Figure 5) or even pedestrians (Figure 6). One prophetic cartoon even addresses the danger of drinking and driving (Figure 7). Other concerns include the cost of car ownership, concerns about breakdowns with few service stations, and limited roads. The daunting number of choices concerning cars might have contributed to inertia. Potential car owners had to choose between numerous new car companies, all vying for their business. They also had to decide between a gas powered and an electric powered vehicle. Surprisingly, electric powered cars were more popular at first, until the self-starter began replacing the hand crank around 1912.[20] Even the position of the steering wheel required the buyer to make a decision. Many of the vehicles in Life’s “Auto Number” have the steering wheel on the right side (including the cover by C. Coles Phillips), even though driving on the right side of the road was already established.[21] (Figure 8) Ford models had the steering wheel on the left side starting in 1908, but standardizing the position of the steering wheel on the left side did not occur until a few years later.[22]

During this period of rapid change, magazine cover art displayed images of the horse-drawn carriage as well as the automobile. One example is the illustration on the cover of the 10 February 1912 issue of Collier’s, The National Weekly. (Figure 9) Collier’s, a general interest magazine which included current events, was published from 1888 to 1957.[23] The cover illustration by Adolph Treidler— who had a distinguished career in illustration creating artwork for many magazines and travel posters in support of war efforts during both World War I and World War II—shows a group of elegantly attired men and women surrounding a whip-bearing driver of a horse-drawn vehicle. The figures’s poise and boldly stylish apparel draw the viewer to the scene. Even the top-hatted driver exudes an air of authority.

The illustration is stylized and sophisticated, while realistic as opposed to nonrepresentational. Its paucity of detail and the simplified pattern on one woman’s coat gives it modern flair. This 1912 illustration hints at the beginnings of Art Deco styling, which became increasingly popular in the 1920s and 1930s.[24] “Borrowing from Cubist blocks, Fauvist colors, and Futurist motion, Art Deco artists created bold, simple designs suitable for mass production,” writes curator Paula A. Baxter in a brochure for the 2009 Art Deco Design: Rhythm and Verve exhibit at the New York Public Library.[25] Treidler’s 1912 cover illustration contains elements of Baxter’s description. The simplicity and boldness of the design bestows elegance. Treidler’s illustration was ahead of its time, even predating the 1913 New York Armory Show which is generally associated with introducing modern art to America.[26]

The subject of Treidler’s illustration reveals an ironic twist. While depicting a horse-drawn vehicle, ample evidence indicates that the surrounding men and women are attending an automobile show. Wording on the glass window in the background, while partially blocked and difficult to read, refers to “Knickerboc(ker) The Show,” and a small, indistinct image of an automobile is visible adjacent to the driver. Further evidence is the “Father Knickerbocker Shows ‘1912’ The Latest Models” banner headline which appears with a New York Times article published on January 7, 1912 (one month prior to the publication date of the cover illustration), announcing the show’s glamorous opening:

With the opening of the twelfth National Automobile Show last night at Madison Square Garden the season of 1912 began under the most favorable auspices. Not since the inception of motor car exhibitions has so much real interest been manifested in the industry, and where in former years many of the visitors to the big exhibition buildings were attracted largely by curiosity and because it was the fashion to attend the shows, the public generally has developed into a critical discriminator of the good and bad qualities of the motor car.[27]

Despite the incongruity, it makes sense that automobile show visitors are pictured arriving by a horse-drawn vehicle. These well-to-do men and women are readying themselves to purchase their first car. The cover illustration illuminates the change from non-motorized to motorized personal transportation, one of the most significant technological and marketing feats of the time. Depicting the horse-drawn vehicle and the automobile show in the same image sends the strong message that times are changing.

Another example of persuasive cover art is the cheerful illustration by an unnamed artist of a couple out for a leisurely spin in the country depicted on the July 1915 issue of World’s Advance in Electricity, Mechanics, Invention, Science, one of many new magazines marketed to a public eager to incorporate technology in their lives—and which evolved along with the innovations they promoted. (Figure 10) Wording on the cover and the inside masthead states that this magazine, published in New York City, was formerly Modern Mechanics as well as a consolidation of Popular Electricity and the World’s Advance, Modern Electrics and Mechanics, Electrician and Mechanic.

The cover illustration showing the happy couple in their own car includes accompanying wording which proclaims: “In This Issue ‘HOW TO BUILD A SIMPLE CYCLECAR’.” This would be an easy undertaking, according to the article:

The tools actually required for the construction of our car are comparatively few and simple. The possession of a lathe is a fortunate one, but the amateur who has access to a near-by machine shop need not hesitate to undertake the work, even though he has no lathe of his own. The machine work on the car is very simple and therefore inexpensive, even if done on a time basis in a shop.[28]

This cover is significant for two reasons. First, it heralds the beginnings of automobile tinkering as a favorite pastime for many. Second, the smiling young couple on this cover found a way to afford a car without having to purchase one. They built it themselves, to save money. The message to the viewer is that you, too, can find a way to both afford and enjoy your own automobile.

Racing was another newly emerging automobile-related pastime. One way Americans became aware of racing was through magazine cover illustrations depicting this new leisure activity. Howard V. Brown, who illustrated for magazines such as Astounding Science Fiction, Everyday Engineering, Radio News, Science and Invention, Scientific American[29] and Harper’s Weekly[30], provided the 1 January 1916 Scientific American cover illustration; a striking depiction of car racing. (Figure 11) Distinguished magazine historian Frank Luther Mott describes Scientific American, published throughout its history in New York City,[31] as the “famous popular weekly of general science and mechanics.” He noted in 1957 that it “issued a fiftieth-anniversary number on August 7, 1896.”[32] It is still published today, as a monthly.

Brown—a prolific magazine and children’s book illustrator capable of rendering artwork in many styles—uses bright colors and a blurred atmosphere to give the impression of speed. The racecars are the center of attention in this illustration, and the drivers are secondary. One can almost hear the roar of the engines as the racecars speed past the finish line. At first glance the style seems impressionistic due to its looseness. The subject matter, however, is modern. The racecars’s modern appearance is so remarkable that one finds it hard to accept that this illustration was published ninety-six years ago.

The April 6, 1912 issue of Harper’s Weekly features a beautiful cover illustration created by Brown depicting a New York City street scene with what photographic evidence suggests is the Knickerbocker Trust Company on the northwest corner of 5th Avenue and 34th Street in the background. (Figure 12) In this illustration, Brown shows cars as a natural part of the cityscape, increasing the public’s comfort with the changeover from horses and buggies. Cars predominate in this illustration, and there is only one horse-drawn vehicle. Interestingly, a 1910 photo (Figure 13) which seems remarkably similar to the illustration (and might have been used by Brown as a reference photo) shows additional horse-drawn vehicles.[33] Brown seems partial to the new technology.

This street scene showcases Brown’s extraordinary artistic talent. Its realistic yet aesthetic depiction of people, cars and buildings is reminiscent of similarly appealing renderings of city life created by Ashcan School artists. Nonetheless, according to Brown researcher Steve Kirch, he was perhaps best known for his science fiction art:[34] Kirch notes: “Howard V. Brown probably had as much to do with shaping our concept of the future as any three science or science-fiction writers you could name. What the futurists thought, Howard put into pictures so we could immediately see what it would be like.”[35] Brown’s racecar illustration, while different from his street scene and science fiction art, also exhibits his extraordinary talent. He was as capable of creating art that dramatically portrayed the era in which he lived and worked, as well as his era’s perception of the future. Multi-talented as a creator of diverse forms of art, it is unfortunate that few people today recognize his name.

A friendly race between an automobilist and a motorcyclist appears on the cover illustration of the August 23, 1919 Literary Digest. (Figure 14) According to Peterson, this New York City-based magazine was founded in 1890 by Dr. Isaac K. Funk and Adam W. Wagnalls “to winnow instructive material from the periodicals of their day,” and “The man who probably did most to guide the Literary Digest into becoming a national institution was Robert J. Cussihy, its publisher from 1905 to 1937.”[36] The two motorized vehicles pictured on the cover create a cloud of dirt from the ground as they speed, side by side, up a countryside hill. This illustration, created by Leon Alaric Shafer, is not full color yet it is full of life. The two drivers are confident competitors who appear quite adept at handling the new technology. Shafer’s illustration emphasizes the motorcyclist by placing him in the foreground. It introduces its audience to motorcycling as an alternative means of motorized transportation.

Unfortunately, there is scant information on Leon Alaric Shafer (who signed his work L.A. Shafer) even though he created magazine cover illustrations for the American Legion monthly and the Literary Digest as well as World War I posters.[37] He also worked as an etcher and as a fine artist, and created marine art as well as striking, impressionistic paintings of the 1906 San Francisco fire. Shafer was born in Illinois in 1866, and he exhibited at the Art Institute of Chicago in 1897 and 1905. He later moved to New York, and died in 1940.[38]

Magazine cover art from the late Progressive Era also shows women’s eager acceptance of the automobile in their lives. Viewing these images of women’s ease with automobile travel and ownership made more women comfortable with automobiles, and thereby expanded automobile acceptance even more. The humorous yet telling illustration on the cover of the March 8, 1913 issue of Truth (Figure 15) is evidence of the fact that women as well as men were attracted to automobiles from the earliest stages. The illustration depicts a fashionable woman, encircled by a tire, smiling at the car in her hand. She does not even notice the dejected man at her side. The illustration is entitled “JILTED.” The automobile is so important to the woman that it has replaced the man as her first love.

The illustrator’s name is not apparent on this image, but the woman is rendered in the fashion of a Gibson Girl or Christy Girl, so named after their creators Charles Dana Gibson and Howard Chandler Christy. These idealized images portrayed women of the time as beautiful, confident, and adventuresome—and they were rendered by many illustrators, both male and female. The subject of this illustration causes one to ponder the gender of the unsigned artist who created it. Regardless, the resemblance of the woman in the “Jilted” illustration to the feminine ideal likely sparked the interest of female viewers of this image to start their own love affair with an automobile.

The colorful January 1916 Metropolitan magazine cover illustration of a woman driver (Figure 1 at top) also serves to lure women to the joys of car ownership. Created by Penrhyn Stanlaws, it presents a large full color image of a beguiling young woman driving confidently in a roofless vehicle through gentle snowflakes. Metropolitan, published in New York City, featured fiction by renowned writers as well as “Special Articles” and “Features” to keep readers informed. The sophisticated female driver gracing the cover is dressed warmly and fashionably in a red coat and matching hat with feathery material gracefully streaming with the wind. Her ebony fur scarf and light gloves complete the picture of comfort and entitlement. Despite the inclement weather, the driver assuredly faces the viewer instead of the road. Handling a car is a statement of joy, not trepidation. Other young women viewing this engaging magazine cover image, might, in turn, be eager to drive cars of their own.

Penrhyn Stanlaws, similar to Gibson and Christy and other illustrators of the time, specialized in images of attractive women. Illustration experts Walt and Roger Reed describe his work:

Penrhyn was completely absorbed in the presentation of pretty girls and did so with great success. Their beautiful faces appeared on most of the magazines including The Saturday Evening Post, Associated Sunday MagazineHearst’s International, and Metropolitan magazine.[39]

Stanlaws died in 1957. His New York Times obituary tells that “Hollywood used his soft and fluffy feminine creation to advertise early motion pictures.” The article adds other information about his remarkable accomplishments:

He was born in Dundee, Scotland. He came to the United States and entered Princeton University in 1901, using his artistic talents to pay his way through the four years. From Princeton he went to Paris ‘To study real art.’ After several years he returned and created the ‘Stanlaws Girl.’ It was an immediate success with magazine editors. His connection with the motion picture industry led to a brief respite from the easel. He directed the motion picture ‘The Little Minister,’ starring Betty Compson. He once worked for the art staff of the Chicago Daily News and was a regular for the cover of the Saturday Evening Post. He came to Los Angeles in the early Nineteen Forties. Since then he had done mainly portrait work.[40]

Although talented and accomplished, Stanlaws did not achieve the level of lasting fame as other illustrators who specialized in portraying beautiful women such as Gibson and Christy.

Reliable transportation has always been the automobile’s primary purpose. This message was also delivered via magazine covers. One example is the beautifully illustrated December 2, 1916 Literary Digest cover, another creation by L.A. Shafer. (Figure 16) The cover depicts a family, comfortable and warm in a large car, approaching a house on a snowy evening. The wreath displayed incongruously at the top of the scene indicates that the family is visiting for Christmas. The black automobile is driven by a chauffeured driver. This is either a prosperous city family that has no need of their own car, or a family of more modest means that needed to hire a cab. The black silhouette of the car, with a touch of warmth from its lit interior, contrasts with the dimness of the snowy night. The message here is that the car, protective and strong, makes this holiday visit possible.

Another effect of the changeover to automobiles was the expansion of recreational travel. Travelers with access to automobiles no longer had to rely on trains and horse-drawn vehicles to arrive at their destinations. Automobiles allowed people to travel quickly from door-to-door. This speed and convenience made day trips practical. The growing population living near or in cities could escape by car for brief visits to the countryside. The large number of people who still lived in rural areas could travel quickly to town or to a nearby city for shopping, culture or entertainment.

Automobiles initially also helped bring families closer. This was a time of growing respect toward children, as Collier Schorr, author of The Essential Norman Rockwell, explains:

Between the turn of the century and about 1915, America discovered Childhood and Youth. The Victorian middle-class legacy of ‘children should be seen and not heard’ gave way to the belief that children and teenagers did indeed have something to say and were worth adult investment in their future as good citizens and responsible, self-sufficient consumers.[41]

Parents now wanted to spend time with their children on day excursions or lengthier vacations. The family automobile made this possible.

The October 28, 1916 Judge cover illustration, “Sour Grapes,” (Figure 17) shows the joyfulness of a family automobile excursion while poking fun at the ignoble side of human nature. Those who have not yet achieved this most recent indicator of American success—automobile ownership—are understandably envious of those who have. The illustrator, Emil Flohri, cleverly writes excuses on the grapes in the foreground of this scenic vista, showing his humor as well as his artistry. The humor magazine Judge was the perfect venue for this slice-of-life artistry. Peterson records that “Judge began existence in October, 1881, by announcing editorially that it was ‘started…for fun’ and that ‘money is no object.’”[42] It was published in New York City by the Leslie-Judge Company.

According to his 1938 New York Times obituary, Emil Flohri began working for Leslie’s Magazine as its “Washington political cartoonist and illustrator” when he was just sixteen. He later became a portrait artist for silent screen movie stars. The obituary states that Flohri’s “‘full dinner pail’ cartoons helped elect William McKinley President.” It also mentions that “he had been associated with the Walt Disney studios for ten years.”[43] He died at his home in Van Nuys, California at the age of sixty-nine. Despite Flohri’s diverse capabilities as an artist, a cartoonist, an illustrator, and a humorist, his name is surprisingly unrecognizable today.

Ironically, the automobile—a symbol of the machine age—allowed a growing urban population to reconnect with nature. The prominent inclusion of an automobile in the 3 December 1910 Harper’s Weekly cover illustration (Figure 18) provides aesthetic representation of this new interest. Interestingly, Harper’s Weekly, published from 1857 to 1916, featured full-color cover illustrations while Harper’s (with copious inside illustrations by well-known illustrators) primarily retained its original staid look over time.[44] The two attractive young couples in this cover illustration break for a cookout beside a wooded lake while touring the countryside. Their sophisticated yet semi-casual attire suggests that their homes are urban, not rural. The automobile makes it possible for them to explore the wholesomeness of the natural environment, for which they have a yearning. This engaging illustration is skillfully rendered by W.H.D. Koerner who received art training from famed illustrators Stanley Massey Arthurs, Harvey Dunn, Howard Pyle, Frank Earle Schoonover, and N.C.Wyeth.[45] His fine realistic style reflects that of his teachers. Koerner’s biographer W.H. Hutchinson exultingly describes him as “the most dependable of the great magazine illustrators when the mass-circulation magazines were the television screens of their day and their advertisements were the commercials.”[46] Hutchinson also adds to the continuing discussion of the value of illustration versus fine art by pointing out that Koerner, like Winslow Homer and Remington, viewed illustration as “a vivid form of art and he gave his best to it.”[47]

Despite Hutchinson’s acclaim that Koerner was “the most dependable of the great magazine illustrators,” he gives two reasons to explain why Koerner “until recently, has been so little known and even less recognized.” Koerner, unfortunately, was like so many other fine illustrators in this regard, and these reasons apply to them as well. The first reason is the “peculiar cannons by which artists, art critics, and art collectors, be they competent or self-anointed, distinguish between illustrators and those who do ‘easel painting.’” Hutchinson quotes Frank Luther Mott to dispute the denigration of illustration as an “impure,” lesser form of art. In Mott’s words: “Art criticism is a field from which the dogmatist should be barred.” The second reason is that “an invidious distinction between those who illustrate books and those whose work is done primarily for magazines.” Hutchinson continues: “It is impossible to find a serious discussion of magazine illustrators and their works, although it is comparatively easy to locate learned disquisitions on book illustrators and their works.”[48] It is time to restore deserved credit to the extraordinarily talented magazine cover illustrators—Koerner and many others—who aesthetically documented and gently influenced the American lifestyle during the 1910s. These are the artists who brought art to the masses.



Magazine cover art displayed the growing impact of automobiles—and sometimes racecars and motorcycles—during the late Progressive Era, extending their appeal to the American public. Cover illustrations depicted the changeover to motorized vehicles and increased the public’s comfort level with this new technology, showing the many ways that automobiles could enrich the lives of everyday Americans. Automobiles especially, by transforming our means of transportation, also affected our relationships and our recreational pursuits. Automobiles altered the lives of Americans in many ways, and magazine cover illustrations played a large part in making this happen. The appealing artwork on the covers of magazines proved to an eager audience of both women and men that automobiles were for visiting, fun, adventure, and vacationing, as well as for more practical uses such as commuting. Magazine cover art was not the sole factor in the expansion of automobile usage, but it certainly boosted it. Meanwhile, talented cover artists provided the public with lifestyle changing messages along with their artwork.

A century has passed since these automobile cover images were published in nationally distributed magazines. Revisiting them entertains today’s viewers with a nostalgic journey through time. However, just as the original images purported to both enlighten and entertain, viewing these images today encourages contemplation as well as amusement. One gives thought to the artistic value of the illustrations, as well as to granting overdue recognition to the men and women who created them.

The persuasive messages imbedded in these images also invite thoughts concerning the value of the changes they precipitated and the changes that society will undertake in the future. The cover illustrations boosted magazine sales as well as eased the public through the tumultuous changes of their times, such as the shift to motorized personal transportation. Gas-powered vehicles including Ford’s Model-T and the development of numerous related industries created a prosperous economy and triggered the expansion of suburbia. Magazine cover illustrations depicted the many positive aspects of this changeover in transportation: the thrill of modernity, the enjoyment of a new hobby, independence, travel, comfort, family togetherness, and the joyfulness of connecting with nature.

While acknowledging that the positives related to last century’s changeover to motorized personal transportation still remain, today’s perspective offers suggestions on needed changes and enhancements. Foremost is the urgency for innovative technologies that will reduce pollution and concerns about climate change. New York Times columnist Thomas L. Friedman writes about this in 2012 in “Take the Subway”:

There will be two billion more people here by 2050, and they will all want to live and drive just like us. And when they do, there is going to be one monster traffic jam and pollution cloud, unless we learn how to get more mobility, lighting, heating and cooling from less energy and with less waste—with so many more people.[49]

Friedman’s concerns for the future recall the wording by the unsigned author of “The Lure of the Auto” (1910): “It is lucky that autos are dear. If they were not, there would be so many of them that there would not be room on the earth for the folks to move about.”[50] In another reminder of the past, Friedman quotes James Bradfield Moody, co-author with Bianca Nogrady of The Sixth Wave: How to Succeed in a Resource Limited World, recounting the times when increasing consumerism boosted the economy. This is reminiscent of the public’s eagerness to purchase automobiles in the 1910s and the resulting growth of the automobile and related industries, and the economy as a whole. Friedman writes:

In the past, says Moody, ‘the more we consumed, the more we grew.’ And therefore, there was a tension between green and gold. But that cannot last, says Moody. When you have a global market, with a burgeoning population, that faces rising scarcity of resources and still so much waste in how we make and consume things there is a great market opportunity for innovation.[51]

Friedman is optimistic that American ingenuity and innovation will overcome pollution and climate change problems. To support his claim, he mentions the efforts of Amory Lovins, chairman of the Rocky Mountain Institute and author of Reinventing Fire: Bold Business Solutions for the New Energy Era. Friedman explains:

The Rocky Mountain Institute and its business collaborators show how private enterprise–motivated by profit, supported by smart policy–can lead America off both oil and coal by 2050, saving $5 trillion, through innovation emphasizing design and strategy. “You don’t have to believe in climate change to solve it,” says Lovins. “Everything we do to raise energy efficiency will make money, improve security and health, and stabilize climate.”[52]

Friedman’s optimism is refreshingly reminiscent of an earlier time in history when the rapid succession of exciting innovations, including motorized transportation, brought change and lifestyle enhancement. It is comforting to consider that we are living in a new era of both change and betterment for society. A century later, viewers comprehend that the significance of the change in transportation is still evolving. Once again, Americans need advice on coping with the many effects of the vast numbers of gas powered vehicles. The illustrations of the past incite interest in finding solutions to the situation in the present and the future.


Dr. June S. Knopf is a writer and researcher with special interests in the interdisciplinary fields of visual culture and magazine history. She received the Doctor of Letters (D.Litt) from Drew University’s Caspersen School of Graduate Studies in May 2011.



[1] “Timeline: History of the Electric Car.” Accessed January 2012 via

[2] Andrew Strieber, “T Party—Ford Celebrates 100th Birthday of the Model T: We Take a Spin in a Tin Lizzy,” Motor Trend, July 2008. Accessed January 2012 via

[3] Theodore Peterson, Magazines in the Twentieth Century (Urbana, Illinois: University of Illinois Press, 1964), 1.

[4] Ibid., 5.

[5] John Tebbel and Mary Ellen Zuckerman, The Magazine in America: 1741-1990 (New York: Oxford UP, 1991), 63.

[6] American Art Review, 1880, in Tebbel and Zuckerman, Magazine in America: 1741-1990, 63.

[7] Theodore Peterson, Magazines in the Twentieth Century, (Urbana, Illinois: University of Illinois Press, 1964), 1.

[8] Walt Reed, “Introduction—Illustration, A Look Back.” In Arpi Ermoyan, Famous American Illustrators, (London: Quantum Publishing, Ltd., 2002), 6.

[9] “A Latter-day Industry and Its Rewards,” New York Times, February 6, 1910.

[10] Ibid.

[11] “The Twentieth Century 1910 – 1919,” Lone Star College—Kingwood, American Cultural History.

Accessed March 2012 via

[12] Steven Lomazow, American Periodicals, A Collector’s Manual and Reference Guide (Fairfield, NJ: Horowitz/Rae Book Manufacturers, 1996), 404.

[13] Susan E. Meyer, James Montgomery Flagg (New York: Watson-Guptill Publications, 1974), 37.

[14] “Smith, Jessie Wilcox,” Penn State Center for the History of the Book. Accessed March 2012 via

[15] “A Latter-day Industry and Its Rewards,” New York Times, February 6, 1910.

[16] Patricia Frantz Kery. Great Magazine Covers of the World (New York: Abbeville Press, 1982), 19.

[17] William Reno Kane, ed., 1001 Places to Sell Manuscripts (Ridgewood, NJ: The Editor Company, 1915). Accessed January 2012 via

[18] “Bicycle Industry Falling Off,” New York Times, March 12, 1906.

[19] “The Lure of the Auto,” Life, Auto Number, January 6, 1910, LV, no. 1 419, collection of June S. Knopf, 32.

[20] “Automobile History,” in Bentley Historical Library, University of Michigan. Accessed March 2012 via

[21] “World Standards—Why Do Some Countries Drive on the Right and Others on the Left?” Accessed March 2012 via

[22] Ibid.

[23] Frank Luther Mott, History of American Magazines 1885-1905, 4 (Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard UP, 1957), 453.

[24] Ian Chilvers, “Art Deco,” The Oxford Companion to Western Art, Hugh Brigstocke, ed., Oxford Art Online, 7 May, 2009. Accessed May 2009 via

[25] Paula A. Baxter, pamphlet for Art Deco Design: Rhythm and Verve, exhibit at New York Public Library, 2009.

[26] Rebecca Zurier, Picturing the City, Urban Vision and the Ashcan School, (Berkeley and Los Angeles: The University of California Press, 2006), 23.

[27] “Father Knickerbocker Shows 1912 the Latest Models,” New York Times, January 7, 1912.

[28] “How to Build a Simple Cyclecar,” July, 1915 World’s Advance in Electricity, Mechanics, Invention, Science, private collection of June S. Knopf, 97.

[29] Steve Kirch, “Howard V. Brown, Artist of Technical Subjects,” Magazine Art, Accessed May 2009 via

[30] Howard V. Brown, Harper’s Weekly, April 6, 1912, collection of June S. Knopf.

[31] Daniel C. Schlenoff, Senior Copy Editor, Scientific American, e-mail correspondence, January 25, 2012.

[32] Mott, History of American Magazines 1885-1905, 306-307.

[33] “Knickerbocker Trust Company, 1910,” Digital Murray Hill. Accessed February 2011 via

[34] Steve Kirch, “Howard V. Brown, Artist of Technical Subjects,” Magazine Art. Accessed May 2009 via

[35] Ibid.

[36] Theodore Peterson, Magazines in the Twentieth Century (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1964), 336, 154.

[37] Peter Falk, “L.A. Shafer 1866-1940,” in Who Was Who in American Art. Accessed May 2009 via

[38] Ibid.

[39] Walt and Roger Reed, The Illustrator in America 1880-1980: A Century of Illustration, (New York: Published for the Society of Illustrators by Madison Square Press, 1984), 105.

[40] “STUDIO FIRE KILLS STANLAWS, ARTIST; Originator of Magazine Girl Killed at 80 on Coast– Active in Recent Years,” New York Times, May 20, 1957.

[41] Collier Schorr, The Essential Norman Rockwell (New York: Wonderland Press, 1999), 34.

[42] Theodore Peterson, Magazines in the Twentieth Century, 162.

[43] “Emil Flohri, “Cartoonist of ‘Full Dinner Pail’ Fame Dies in West,” New York Times.

[44] Harper’s Magazine. Accessed January 2012 via

[45] Walt and Roger Reed, The Illustrator in America, 131.

[46] W. H. Hutchinson, The World, The Work, and the West of W. H. D. Koerner (Oklahoma: The University of Oklahoma Press, 1978), 3.

[47] Ibid., 5.

[48] Ibid.

[49] Thomas L. Friedman, “Take the Subway,” New York Times, March 4, 2012, 11.

[50] “The Lure of the Auto,” Life, Auto Number, January 6, 1910, LV, no. 1 419, collection of June S. Knopf, 32.

[51] James Bradfield Moody, quoted in Thomas L. Friedman, “Take the Subway,” New York Times, March 4, 2012, 11.

[52] Amory Lovins, quoted in Thomas L. Friedman, “Take the Subway,” New York Times, March 4, 2012, 11.



American Art Review, 1880. In John Tebbel and Mary Ellen Zuckerman, The Magazine in America: 1741-1990.

“Automobile History.” In Bentley Historical Library, University of Michigan. Accessed March 2012 via

Baxter, Paula A. Pamphlet for Art Deco Design: Rhythm and Verve, exhibit at New York Public Library, 2009.

“Bicycle Industry Falling Off,” New York Times, March 12, 1906.

Brown, Howard V. Harper’s Weekly, April 6, 1912. Collection of June S. Knopf.

Brown, Howard V. Scientific American, January 1, 1916. Drew University Library.

Chilvers, Ian. “Art Deco.” The Oxford Companion to Western Art, Art. Hugh Brigstocke, ed. Oxford Art Online. Accessed May 2009 via

“Emil Flohri, Cartoonist of ‘Full Dinner Pail’ Fame Dies in West.” New York Times.

Ermoyan, Arpi. Famous American Illustrators. Rotovision, Brighton, UK: 1997; reprint, London: Quantum Books, 2002.

Falk, Peter. “L.A. Shafer 1866-1940,” in Who Was Who in American Art. (accessed May 7, 2009).

“Father Knickerbocker Shows 1912 the Latest Models.” New York Times, January 7, 1912.

Flohri, Emil. “Sour Grapes.” Judge, October 28, 1916. Collection of June S. Knopf.

Friedman, Thomas L. “Take the Subway,” New York Times Sunday Review section. March 4, 2012.

Harper’s Magazine. (accessed January 25, 2012).

“How to Build a Simple Cyclecar.” World’s Advance In Electricity, Mechanics, Invention, Science, July, 1915. Collection of June S. Knopf.

Hutchinson, W. H. The World, The Work, and The West of W. H. D. Koerner. Oklahoma: The University of Oklahoma Press, 1978.

“Jilted.” Truth, March 8, 1913. Collection of Steven Lomazow, West Orange, NJ.

Kane, William Reno, ed. 1001 Places to Sell Manuscripts. Ridgewood, NJ: The Editor Company, 1915. (accessed January 27, 2012).

Kery, Patricia Frantz. Great Magazine Covers of the World. New York: Abbeville Press, 1982.

Kirch, Steve. “Howard V. Brown, Artist of Technical Subjects.” Magazine Art. (accessed May 7, 2009).

“Knickerbocker Trust Company, 1910.” Digital Murray Hill. murrayhill/items/show/116 (accessed February 28, 2011).

Koerner, W. H. D. Harper’s Weekly, December 3, 1910. Collection of June S. Knopf.

“A Latter-day Industry and Its Rewards.” New York Times, (no byline) February 6, 1910.

Life, January 6, 1910. Collection of June S. Knopf.

Lomazow, Steven, M.D. American Periodicals: Collector’s Manual and Reference Guide. West Orange, NJ: Horowitz/Rae Book Manufacturers, 1996.

Lovins, Amory. Quoted in Thomas L. Friedman, “Take the Subway,” New York Times Sunday Review section, March 4, 2012.

“The Lure of the Auto.” Life, Auto Number, January 6, 1910, LV, no.1 419. Collection of June S. Knopf.

Meyer, Susan E. James Montgomery Flagg. New York: Watson-Guptill Publications, 1974.

Moody, James Bradfield. Quoted in Thomas L. Friedman, “Take the Subway.” New York Times Sunday Review section, March 4, 2012.

Mott, Frank Luther. A History of American Magazines 1895-1905, vol, 4. Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard UP, 1957.

Peterson, Theodore. Magazines in the Twentieth Century. 2nd ed. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, 1964.

Reed, Walt. “Introduction: Illustration Looks Back.” In Famous American Illustrators, by Ermoyan, Arpi. London: Quantum Publishing Ltd., 2002.

Reed, Walt and Roger. The Illustrator in America 1880-1980, a Century of Illustration. New York: Published for the Society of Illustrators by Madison Square Press, 1984.

Schlenoff, Daniel C. Senior Copy Editor, Scientific American. Email correspondence, January 25, 2012.

Schorr, Collier. The Essential Norman Rockwell. New York: Wonderland Press, 1999.

Shafer, L.A. Literary Digest. December 2, 1916. Drew University Library.

Shafer, L.A. Literary Digest, August 23, 1919. Drew University Library.

“Smith, Jessie Wilcox,” Penn State Center for the History of the Book. (accessed March 26, 2012).

Stanlaws, Penrhyn. Metropolitan, January 1916. Collection of June S. Knopf.

Strieber, Andrew. “T Party–Ford Celebrates 100th Birthday of the Model T: We Take a Spin in a Tin Lizzy.” Motor Trend, July 2008. Accessed January 2012 via

“STUDIO FIRE KILLS STANLAWS, ARTIST; Originator of Magazine Girl Killed at 80 on Coast—Active in Recent Years.” New York Times, May 20, 1957.

Tebbel, John and Mary Ellen Zuckerman. The Magazine in America: 1741-1990. New York: Oxford UP, 1991.

“Timeline: History of the Electric Car.” (accessed January 23, 2012).

Treidler, Adolph. Collier’s The National Weekly, February 10, 1912. In The Illustrator in America 1880-1980: A Century of Illustration, Walt and Roger Reed. New York: Madison Square Press, 1984.

“The Twentieth Century 1910-1919.” Lone Star College – Kingwood, American Cultural History. (accessed March 26, 2012).

“World Standards-Why Do Some Countries Drive on the Right and Others on the Left?” (accessed March 6, 2012).

Zurier, Rebecca. Picturing the City, Urban Vision and the Ashcan School. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2006.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: