Z e t e o
Reading, Looking, Listening, . . . Questioning

The drawbacks of ethnic product placement

Categories: Alexia Raynal, ZiR


Or On the Importance of Inclusion

5-PURA-BELPRE-580x663

Pura Belpré

To some extent, ethnic art (including film and literature) has been recognized as an empowering tool for minorities. Latino and African-American advocates have consistently pushed for the inclusion of content reflecting the lives and struggles of people of color in art and at school. But while these stories have gradually made it into the market, they have nonetheless preserved their ethnic labels. For example, movies with African-American casts are usually labeled as ethnic films rather than American products more broadly. Is this a problem? Absolutely. Labeling Latino-oriented books as ethnic products makes it almost impossible to normalize these people’s experiences. When material gets segregated this way, it loses its potential to teach larger lessons for people of all races.

Marilisa Jiménez-García elaborates on this topic in her blog article Diversity in Children’s Literature and the Legacy of Pura Belpré:

Diversity should be understood as a conversation, rather than as a system of containing U.S. populations as compartments (with respective histories, literature, and cultural iconography) that never converge. A compartmentalized view hinders our ability to envision people of color as participants in the imagined landscapes of American history and culture—past, present, and future. Even our prizing system, including the Belpré Medal, tends to follow this logic of best Latino children’s literature, best African American children’s literature, but when it comes to best American children’s literature, people of color have historically fared in the single digits.

Reflecting on the literary work of Puerto Rican writer Pura Belpré as well as her own work as a literature teacher, Jiménez-García elaborates:

Belpré’s stories were based on folklore which some Latino/a children might find familiar. But, Belpré’s books are also artistic fiction. In other words, they are just stories to be enjoyed by whoever might enjoy them. As a teacher, I had to check my use of the term “relatable” when discussing literature with young people. Once we were reading The Outsiders (1967) and Nicholasa Mohr’s Nilda (1973) as means of comparing how young people grow up and encounter violence. I always remember one student closing her copy of Nilda, saying, “This is about culture, not about teens. I couldn’t really relate.” I was puzzled seeing that key characters in both books were adolescents. Certainly, when a Latino/a author writes about Latino/a characters, the story is shaped by Latino/a culture—which also varies in terms of racial, regional, gender, and national identity. But, the same is true for any author. Oliver Twist is a mainstream story, but it is also a commentary on 19th century childhood—a celebrated time for some who could afford it—and the conditions for poor, orphaned youth. Stories are always about culture. Yet, what we catalogue as “foreign” or “other” tells us more about ourselves than about the stories we read

Marilisa Jimenez-Garcia, is research associate at the Center for Puerto Rican Studies, Hunter College, CUNY. She is also a National Council for Teachers of English (NCTE) Cultivating New Voices Among Scholar of Color Fellow. Visit Lee & Low Books to read more articles on race, diversity, education, and children’s books.

— Alexia Raynal, Zeteo Associate Editor

Ethnic minority 'dolls'

To read more posts in the fields of children and childhood by Alexia Raynal, visit her ZiR page here.

CLICK HERE to subscribe to parts or all of Zeteo. $0. Thoughts many.

Leave a Reply